Skip to main content

The Wrong Mother by Sophie Hannah



This must be fantastic cover day at A Passion for Books.

I read such a variety of views of The Wrong Mother by Sophie Hannah (2009) on blogs that I had to read the book for myself. I find myself falling firmly in the "didn't enjoy this book" category. The cover is actually my favorite part of the book, which is really a sad comment.

My biggest complaint is that the story shifts to so many different points of view that I didn't feel like any one character received decent development.

--There's harried mother Sally Thorning, who had a one-week affair with a man a year ago. A man who now has a dead wife and child, and--wait--the man shown on t.v. as the grieving widower/father isn't the man with whom she had an affair. And Sally is a look-alike for the dead woman.

--There's the Geraldine we think we know as seen through the horrific snips from her diary. She's the dead woman, who police believe killed her daughter, Lucy, before killing herself.

A snip from the diary as found at Kindle locations 593-601:

I have a rule that I've made for myself, and that I stick to come what may: whatever I feel inside, however I feel like behaving towards Lucy, I do the opposite. So when she cried after I'd closed her door, I went back into her room, stroked her hair and said, "What's the matter, love?" because what I really wanted to do was drag her out of her bed and shake her until her teeth fall out.

--DC Simon Waterhouse (policeman), veteran enough to realize that something more is happening with the murder investigation than a simple murder/suicide.

--Charlie Zailer (policewoman), Simon's former associate and love interest.

--DC Colin Sellers (policeman). . . . You get the idea.

Just too many perspectives and not enough depth in any one to hold my attention. Way before the story's end, I really didn't care what happened to Geraldine and Lucy, which isn't like me at all, particularly not when a young child is involved.

My overall personal rating of The Wrong Mother is a C-.

Comments

StephanieD said…
I do remember seeing this cover some months ago and thinking how cool it was. The premise too sounds intriguing. Too bad all that promise didn't follow through.
There's even a nice twist in the mystery, too, but I just couldn't get my mind around all of the different points of view in such a (relatively) short book.

Popular posts from this blog

If Nobody Speaks of Remarkable Things by Jon McGregor

The May selection for my work book club is Jon McGregor's If Nobody Speaks of Remarkable Things (2002). The novel follows various individuals in one neighborhood on a particular day, an ordinary day that ends with a terrible tragedy.

Here's the short set of questions I e-mailed to book club members yesterday, along with my own responses.

Did you have a favorite character, or one that spoke to you the most? Who and why?
The father with the burned hands is the one who stayed with me the most after reading the book.

Did you notice that the day on which the events unfold is actually the same day that Diana, Princess of Wales, died? Does knowing that make any difference in how you see the story? I wouldn't have made the connection if I hadn't just watched some of the coverage of the Royal Wedding. To quote the author, he chose this particular day because his novel is about how ". . .everyday miracles of life and death go unwitnessed in favor of celebrity and sensati…

Current Little Pleasures

Girls' weekend in Omaha with Maya and her friend.

Happy Buddha:  Sweet Orange and Cedar Shower Foam from RITUALS

Time for iced or blended peppermint mochas.

Shopping for little gifts for Maya's Japanese pen pal.  They were matched through their schools, and we're hoping she can stay with us for a few days this summer.

The flock of wild turkeys, foxes, and other assorted wildlife entertaining us this fall.

Thanksgiving plans to visit my sister.

Hallmark Channel's Countdown to Christmas is back!

Current Little Pleasures

Christmas Keepsake Week, July 14-23, filled with Christmas movies on the Hallmark Channel.

Sending Christmas (in July) cards with a Peace greeting to some of my favorite people.  Why not??

Scott Tube Free Toilet Paper--nothing to recycle.

Haagen-Dazs Coffee Ice Cream--always!

Baby Driver movie.

Seeing photos from my sisters and niece on Facebook during their Italy trip.  I can't imagine they will want to come back home!

What are your current little pleasures?